Asmodee Arkham Horror The Card Game The Feast of Hemlock Vale Campaign Expansion - Discover a Mysterious Forbidden Isle, Cooperative LCG, Ages 14+, 1-4 Players, 1-2 Hour Playtime

It's an excellent game to play

After some trial and error with the last two expansions (Scarlet Keys and Edge of the Earth), I'm very happy to report that this expansion strikes a perfect balance between injecting more plot and atmosphere into the campaign, but doing so in such a fun, bite-sized and organic way that you would want to explore every part of it.The scenarios are excellent and some are so innovative that they made me gag with excitement just by reading how to set them up, hinting about what I'm about to face, and STILL surprising me throughout. On top of that, and without spoiling anything, the replayability is very high with this one so you're also getting a lot of bang for your buck. A true triumph for Arkham.

Bless and curse are fun mechanics. Good set for people with a decent sized collection.

Box came with dents and a tear but contents were fine.

Kind of bleh.

I haven't had much love for the new style campaigns; EotE ws nice but sometimes hard to handle, SK was IMHO intolerable because of the corny writing and overly broad scope, and now FoHV ... I was really looking forward to this campaign after seeing a lot of positive reviews, but our experience differed.First, the good: the scenarios in this campaign are really impressive, they take AHLCG to new heights in terms of innovative mechanisms. This comes at a price, though: every scenario introduces several new rules which at times are difficult to follow.The amount of excessive campaign book lookups has been significantly reduced compared to SK.The bad: The narrative comes across as very artificial. Ultimately, the "you can do any scenario in any order" attempt to increase replayability makes the story as a whole suffer. There's not much of a narrative arc, which isn't helped by the setup. Our investigators accompany a completely innocent botanical expedition for no reason, encounter nightmarish horrors and then eat dinner as if that was completely normal. Rinse, repeat 3 times. EotE told the best story of the new expansions, and we've gone downhill from there. The preludes are an attempt to move storytelling into some interaction with cards, but feel so constructed and artificial that the net effect is more one of wasting time.This is the first expansion we stopped playing halfway through. For reference, we finished EotE and decided we love it as a whole but hated the ending and hated on SK all the way through but still finished the campaign.