Lip Liner Pencil Set 8 Colors Professional Matte Lipliner with Sharpener Waterproof Long Lasting Smooth Natural Filler Contour Shaping Lip Makeup for Woman Soft Lip Liner Pen Makeup Cosmetic

I was looking for more fall/winter colors and these did the job. Good application and came with a sharpener.. Beautiful colors and easily paired with your favorite lipsticks.

I got actually four or five colors that I wear out of those pencils and I passed the others on to people that wear darker shades and it does what it says it's going to do it lasts longer than any lipstick I have, can't beat the price.

All of these are a nice shade when applied. They stay on for a long time as well. I was surprised at how many of my lipsticks they match to.

I gave these 3 star because they could be richer in color and they smell like color pencils. The colors are pretty though and you get an assortment for your money.

These are great for the price and sustainability. They are very durable and last a long time. They did not smudge or wear out after usage. I received many comments online after my zoom meetings for the day about how “good” I looked! The lasted all day with a great shine.

I'm black. I have two toned lips. The brown does nothing. The pinks and red shades are great. The lip liner doesn't last long I'd have to reapply it. I also have to add a little force to get the product on. Not worth it.

I was not happy with these at all. They are so dry they do not glide at all and are super hard to apply. The colors were also mostly all different shades of nude and didn't even look like the colors on the cap, and didn't have names or descriptions on them so that was also annoying.

I like colors variety in this set